Defense Attorney Secures Four Pretrial Diversions for UF Student Facing 10+ Year Prison Sentence on Felony Fraud Charges

Defense Attorney Secures Four Pretrial Diversions for UF Student Facing 10+ Year Prison Sentence on Felony Fraud Charges
Matt Landsman and Alana Smith

Prosecutors with the Eighth Judicial Circuit State Attorney’s Office (SAO8) have given a current or former student with the University of Florida (UF) pretrial diversions for her felony fraud cases.

Alana Smith, 19, was a UF student at the time of the offense and it remains unclear if she had any significant disciplinary consequences at the university. She is currently trespassed from the area of the crime but not UF campus entirely.

In April, UF Police Department (UFPD) officers charged Smith with eight felonies and six misdemeanors relating to her commission of a series of thefts at the UF Southwest Recreation Center. She rummaged through students’ bags in the locker room and stole several items from multiple victims, to include credit/debit cards.

Initially facing over 40 years in prison, Smith posted a $28,000 bond after her arrest and retained legal counsel from Criminal Defense Attorney Matt Landsman. Her maximum sentence was heavily reduced in June, with prosecutors dropping several of her charges.

GnvInfo attempted to contact Landsman for comment but did not get a response.

Smith was granted pretrial diversions for her felony and the majority of her remaining misdemeanor charges in July. Prosecutors granted her an additional pretrial diversion earlier this month for her final misdemeanor charge.

This means that if Smith can abide by certain conditions established between her attorney and the prosecution until around early 2028, the State will outright drop her charges.

Pretrial Diversion Conditions (Alachua County Court Records)

In comparison to other SAO8 pretrial diversion dispositions, Smith’s case is arguably more reasonable than some prior cases. 

Smith is young, she has a background in sports leadership as a high school student, she appears to have no prior criminal history and the charges are non-violent. Because of the nature of the charges, Smith would’ve had over 15 years of exposure if found guilty of all the counts she took a pretrial diversion for.

Smith's Cases (Alachua County Court Records)

SAO8 has previously granted pretrial diversions in cases of reported domestic violence, as well as at least one case involving alleged sex offender registration violations.

Man Granted Pretrial Diversion in Felony Dating Violence Case
Prosecutors with the Eighth Judicial Circuit State Attorney’s Office (SAO8) granted Brian Joseph Fischbach, 44, a pretrial diversion in his felony dating violence case. On April 17, 2025, police arrested Fischbach on a warrant for a dating violence incident that occurred in October 2024. According to the arrest report,
SAO8 Grants Convicted Sex Offender Pretrial Diversion
Last week, SAO8 granted convicted sexual offender Travis Dewayne Watkins, 47, a pretrial diversion
High Springs Man Gets Pretrial Diversion for Domestic Violence
On January 16, prosecutors with the Eighth Judicial Circuit State Attorney’s Office granted Charles Bryant Cline, 21, a pretrial diversion for one count of misdemeanor domestic battery. This means prosecutors agreed to close the case without an adjudication of guilt as long as he abides by certain conditions. Alachua
Jack Walden

Jack Walden

Jack is an independent journalist and the creator of GnvInfo. From general information, to exposing falsehoods and corruption, Jack seeks to deliver the truth.
Gainesville, FL