Man Sentenced for Violating Felony Domestic Violence Probation

Man Sentenced for Violating Felony Domestic Violence Probation
Matthew Alexander Shirley (ACSO Jail)

Last week, Matthew Alexander Shirley, 23, was sentenced to six months in jail for violating the conditions of his felony domestic violence probation. 

On March 6, 2025, Gainesville Police Department officers arrested Shirley and charged him with domestic battery by strangulation and aggravated battery on a pregnant victim. 

During an argument that occurred on March 2, 2025, the victim attempted to walk away from Shirley, but he grabbed her from behind and restrained her, preventing her from moving. Two days later, Shirley and the victim got into another argument in which he pushed her multiple times into the bedroom and onto the bed. Shirley then pulled the victim forward and strangled her, impeding her ability to breath. 

Surveillance footage captured Shirley pushing the victim into the bedroom.  

The victim went to the hospital to ensure her baby’s safety following the incidents. 

While at the hospital, the victim confronted Shirley over text about the strangulation. Shirley replied, “That wasn’t on purpose seriously, so that’s [what] this is about.” 

The victim told police that “since [Shirley] moved into her apartment about 8 months ago, there has been escalating violence between the two that started as just arguments, but has turned physical over the past few weeks," the arrest report states.

When speaking to police, Shirley said that he pushed the victim because she hit him first. He denied strangling the victim but admitted that he “did push her backwards by placing his hands near her neck because she was hitting him,” the arrest report states.

Judge Adam Lee set the bond at $150,000, which Shirley’s public defender later motioned to reduce. Judge William Davis granted the motion and released Shirley on his own recognizance.

On May 8, 2025, Shirley was accused of violating the conditions of his pretrial release for failing to contact court services. He was not re-arrested and took a no contest plea deal the following month. Davis accepted the agreement that was negotiated between the prosecution and Shirley’s defense, imposing a three-year probation sentence and withholding an adjudication of guilt. Prosecutors dropped the aggravated battery charge after Shirley agreed to plead to the strangulation charge.

Shirley was later charged with violating his probation after failing to enroll in a batterers’ intervention program. 

On August 27, 2026, St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office deputies arrested Shirley for domestic assault, leading to an additional probation violation report. 

On November 3, 2026, Shirley pleaded no contest to domestic assault. Judge Casey Woolsey withheld an adjudication of guilt and imposed no term of incarceration or probation, court records show. 

(St. Johns County Court Records)

On November 10, facing a maximum sentence of five years in prison, Shirley admitted to violating his probation. Judge Robert Groeb overturned the withheld adjudication of guilt, making Shirley a convicted felon. Groeb did not impose prison time, instead sentencing Shirley to 180 days in the county jail with 131 days of credit for time served.

Jack Walden

Jack Walden

Jack is an independent journalist and the creator of GnvInfo. From general information, to exposing falsehoods and corruption, Jack seeks to deliver the truth.
Gainesville, FL