Butler Plaza Groper Sentenced to Probation
Matthew A. Billeyh, 23, has been sentenced to one year of probation and is out of jail.
Case 1
On September 20, Alachua County Sheriff's Office (ACSO) deputies booked Billeyh into jail on a misdemeanor warrant for stalking and battery out of the Gainesville Police Department (GPD). Billeyh turned himself into jail, court records show.
The incident occurred in January after Billeyh followed the victim around the Butler Plaza Target and slapped her buttocks, surveillance footage shows. Employees rushed to help after observing the victim in distress.

In August, an employee reported that Billeyh returned to the store and indicated that he perpetuated a similar incident against another woman who did not want to report it.
The police report describes multiple potential victims making posts on social media that warn the public of Billeyh. One of the posts shows Billeyh followed another woman around at TJ Maxx, although he did not physically harm her.

"Evidence indicates [Billeyh] is engaged in an ongoing course of criminal conduct that is causing significant distress to the public," reported GPD Detective Desiree Russano. "Training and experience causes [me] to conclude that [Billeyh]'s behavior has the potential to escalate in severity and that [Billeyh] remains an active threat to the public."
Under Florida Statutes, nonconsensual acts such as sexual assault or molestation against victims exceeding the age of consent are generally charged as misdemeanor battery if the act involves groping over clothing and doesn't constitute nonconsensual penetration or union with a sexual organ.
Case 2
On October 14, Russano pressed an additional count of stalking and battery against Billeyh for groping another woman who was shopping with a friend at Marshalls in Butler Plaza. The incident occurred in April.
The victim began feeling uncomfortable after noticing Billeyh was following her around the store. As they passed each other in the same aisle, Billeyh reportedly used his hand to touch the victim's buttocks. The victim rushed over to her friend and went on to report the incident to the store manager.
Russano describes the surveillance footage in her report:
"[Billeyh] is walking away from camera view with a pair of shoes/sandals in [his] left hand. At the same time, [the victim] is approaching the same aisle from the opposite direction. As Billeyh approaches... [he] can be seen transferring the shoes from [his] left hand to [his] right hand and using [his] left hand to touch the [victim]'s buttocks. [The victim]'s physical response is to immediately shift her hips in the direction opposite [Billeyh] and to look back quickly and [concerningly] at [him]. [The victim] then speeds up her pace and rushes to her friend to advise her friend of what just happened."
Formal Charges and Sentence

In late October, prosecutors formally filed a count of battery against Billeyh for the initial case and dropped the stalking charge. The charges from the second case remain in sworn complaint status.

Yesterday, November 18, Billeyh pleaded no contest to battery, which carries a potential one-year jail sentence. Judge Meshon Rawls sentenced Billeyh to one year of probation under the conditions that he not contact the victim and undergo a psychosexual evaluation.

