Defendant’s Brother Disputes Jury Verdict in Shooting Case

Defendant’s Brother Disputes Jury Verdict in Shooting Case
Alachua County Criminal Courthouse (GnvInfo)

Last month, a jury found 27-year-old Roman Carter guilty of aggravated battery with a firearm. The Eighth Judicial Circuit State Attorney’s Office (SAO8) tried to prove him guilty of attempted murder in the first degree, but the jury decided on a lesser-included offense. Chief Judge William Davis presided over the trial.

Carter shot Adrian Dixon during a dispute where they were both in their vehicles. Carter and his family maintain that he was acting in self-defense.

The incident occurred on July 5, 2025, during daylight hours. Gainesville Police Department detectives charged Carter roughly two months later.

The police report suggests that Roman Carter and his brother, Trey Carter, were following Dixon, leading to him brake-checking Roman Carter and a rear-end collision.

During an interview with GnvInfo, Trey Carter said a third party called him asking him to mediate a dispute between Dixon and Roman Carter.

Trey Carter said that he happened to be dropping off his kids at the time and ran into Dixon and his brother soon after getting on the road.

Trey Carter said that Dixon and Roman Carter used to be friends in high school but grew apart after becoming adults.

Trey Carter described his brother and Dixon exchanging words while their cars were side by side. He said he saw Dixon swerve into Roman Carter’s lane before brake-checking, causing their vehicles to collide. This prompted Roman Carter to follow, effectively trying to tell Dixon, “Hey pull over bro you hit my car… Don’t flee you need to answer for this…,” Trey Carter said.

Trey Carter testified as a defense witness at his brother's trial. While maintaining that his brother acted in self-defense, Trey Carter acknowledged Dixon’s injuries were severe, and said he believes the jury reached the lesser-included offense verdict due to the prosecution displaying the graphic nature of the wounds.

Trey Carter expressed concerns about Florida’s minimum mandatory sentencing laws that apply to firearms. Under the law, Roman Carter faces a minimum of 20 years in prison.

The firearm that Roman Carter possessed was legal, and he was licensed to carry at the time of the incident. He has no prior felony or misdemeanor convictions, court records show.

Roman Carter (Facebook)

In 2024, Dixon was arrested for attacking a woman with his vehicle. The initial charge was aggravated battery, but court records show he and his attorney reached an agreement with prosecutors for a probation sentence and charge reduction to aggravated assault. As part of the agreement, Dixon also pleaded no contest to felony property damage ($1,000 or more) and misdemeanor battery in another case.

Adrian Dixon (Facebook)

Roman Carter’s attorney made a motion for a new trial, but it was denied by Davis.

According to the motion, “[Roman Carter] testified that Mr. Dixon threatened to kill him during the confrontation, leaned across the interior of his vehicle, and displayed a firearm in his hand. [A witness] testified that she knew Mr. Dixon and could recognize his voice. On a FaceTime call she [was on] with Roman Carter, she corroborated [the] testimony that Mr. Dixon was making threats… [Trey] Carter testified that he was right behind Roman Carter in traffic when the incident occurred and he could see in Mr. Dixon's car, and saw his shoulder make a movement toward the floor… Mr. Carter testified that he drew his firearm and fired because he believed Mr. Dixon was about to shoot him… Mr. Carter further testified that he stopped firing when he perceived that the threat had ended. That evidence was consistent with a defensive use of force rather than retaliatory or premeditated violence… The State's principal eyewitness to the events immediately preceding the shooting, Mr. Dixon, was unable to reliably contradict significant portions of [Roman Carter]’s account.”

According to the motion, Dixon claimed to have amnesia about the incident but remembered several peripheral details. 

The motion emphasizes that the lesser-included verdict underscores the weakness in the prosecution’s theory. 

When denying the motion, Davis ruled, “None of the verdicts are against the weight of the credible evidence. [Roman Carter] claims he saw Mr. Dixon holding a silver gun through an open front passenger window and fired in self-defense. But the credible evidence established that the window could not have been open: it contained a single clean bullet hole at its bottom, and three additional bullet holes were found in the passenger-side door panel just below the handle. Had the window been down, those three bullets would have shattered or pierced it. [Roman Carter]’s account is therefore inconsistent with the physical evidence.”

“There is video evidence that the window was in fact down,” said Trey Carter in a brief statement following Davis’ decision. “This evidence was even shown in court. We are confident that an appellate lawyer will be able to get a more favorable verdict.”

GnvInfo attempted to contact Dixon via Facebook Messenger to give him the chance to provide his side, but no response has been received. 

Roman Carter sent a letter to Davis in which he stressed that he was trained in self-defense and that he only acted after Dixon pulled a gun on him.

"In today's society we live in, gun violence is so high," Roman Carter said. "I've had several friends die from the cause of it. One died while I have been incarcerated, it has terrified me to this very day."

Roman Carter emphasized that he was honest in his testimony and requested mercy so he can continue to care for his three young children.

Roman Carter's Letter (Alachua County Court Records)

Roman Carter was initially scheduled to be sentenced next week, but it has been rescheduled for tomorrow morning.

Order Rescheduling Sentencing (Alachua County Court Records)

Editor's Notes: More information and quotes from Trey Carter's interview with GnvInfo may be released at a later date.

Jack Walden

Jack Walden

Jack is an independent journalist and the creator of GnvInfo. From general information, to exposing falsehoods and corruption, Jack seeks to deliver the truth.
Gainesville, FL